Less than 20,000 spots remaining · 1 year free Pro provider subscriptions
Claim yours
Craftly
For ProvidersLog in
Back to providersProvider Handbook

How to win on Craftly

Profile setup, photo guidelines, response time, pricing strategy, and the levers that turn free leads into booked clients.

6-min read·Last updated May 2026
On this page (8 sections)▾

How to win on Craftly

Free leads only matter if you can convert them. This handbook is the operational follow-through on the Craftly promise — a short field guide for turning the visitors who land on your profile into booked clients.

It is not theoretical. Every recommendation below is something providers on similar two-sided marketplaces have already tested. Skim the section headers; act on the ones that apply.

Build a profile that gets chosen, not just seen

Showing up in search is half the work. The other half happens in the seconds a visitor spends scanning your card.

The three things visitors check first

1

Your photo

Faces beat logos. A clear, well-lit headshot — eyes visible, neutral background — outperforms studio branding by a wide margin. Replace generic stock or text-only avatars before publishing.

2

Your headline

A visitor decides in roughly two seconds whether to keep reading. Lead with what you do and who you do it for (“Wedding photographer for couples who hate posing”). Save the awards for paragraph three.

3

Your starting price

Listing a starting price filters out window-shoppers and signals confidence. Profiles that hide price are skipped more often than profiles that quote a starting figure with a “from $X” framing.

Profile completeness is a ranking signal

Search ordering on Craftly favors profiles with more complete, fresher content. The minimum bar to take seriously: a real photo, a written bio of at least 150 words, three portfolio items, a service area, and a starting price. Adding credentials, a video intro, or a Verified Badge moves you up further. A blank profile costs you visibility you didn't realize you were giving away.

Portfolio: depth beats polish

A portfolio of fifteen mediocre images is worse than a portfolio of five great ones.

  • Lead with your strongest work. The first three items are what most visitors will see. Put your three best examples there, even if they don't fit the chronology.
  • Show range, then specialize. A photographer who only shows weddings looks like a wedding photographer. If you also shoot families, include one. If you don't, don't pad.
  • Caption your work. "Sunday afternoon family session — Schenley Park, two kids, golden hour" beats "Family Session #14." Visitors imagining themselves in your portfolio convert at higher rates than visitors looking at it abstractly.
  • Refresh quarterly. Stale portfolios read as inactive. Even rotating the order signals freshness.

Response time is a feature

The Craftly messaging system records the time from a connection request to your first reply. Internal data on similar marketplaces shows:

  • Replies within one hour: book at roughly 3× the rate of replies after 24 hours.
  • Replies after 48 hours: a substantial share of consumers have already booked elsewhere.

You don't need to be instant. You need to be predictable. Two practical patterns:

  1. Same-day reply, even if brief. "Got your message — I'll send a full response by tonight" is better than radio silence followed by a polished reply two days later.
  2. Set expectations in your bio. "I respond within 24 hours, usually faster" calibrates the consumer and prevents drop-off.

If you're heads-down on existing work and can't reply quickly, switch your delivery preference to SMS so the alert reaches you faster.

Pricing strategy: anchor, don't undercut

The instinct on a new platform is to lower prices to win business. On Craftly that's the wrong move — and it's structurally not necessary, because Craftly doesn't surface low bids the way lead-gen platforms do. Search results aren't ordered by price.

Three principles:

  • Quote your real rate. If you charge $75/hr off-platform, charge $75/hr on Craftly. Lower rates here signal lower quality and attract clients who don't value your time.
  • Anchor with a starting price. "From $X" gives visitors a number to evaluate against. Hiding price doesn't preserve flexibility — it just loses interest.
  • Price for the value you deliver, not for what competitors are charging. A common mistake is matching the lowest price in your category. The best path is to charge what your work is worth and let the profile defend the number.

Reviews: ask early, ask specifically

Craftly reviews are dual-confirmation — both the consumer and the provider attest to the same engagement, which means review fraud is structurally harder than on other platforms. That makes a single Craftly review more credible than five reviews on a platform without verification.

How to get more of them:

  • Ask within 24 hours of the work. The window between completion and "moving on with their day" is narrow. Don't wait a week.
  • Be specific in the ask. "If you have two minutes, I'd appreciate a Craftly review — feel free to mention the rush turnaround if it stood out" gets longer, more useful reviews than "please leave a review."
  • Don't offer incentives. Reviews offered in exchange for a discount, refund, or free service violate the Community Standards and can result in account suspension.
  • Respond to every review. A short, professional response to a review — positive or negative — signals to future visitors that you take feedback seriously.

The Verified Badge is worth getting

Optional identity verification through Stripe Identity earns you a Verified Badge on your profile. It is the single highest-leverage trust signal Craftly offers consumers.

Why it matters:

  • Verified profiles appear higher in search rankings as a tiebreaker when other factors are equal.
  • Consumers filter on "Verified only" — without the badge, you don't appear in those results.
  • Early-adopter providers get the Verified Badge free for their first year (a $50+ value).

The verification process takes about three minutes. Stripe handles the ID document and selfie; Craftly only ever sees a pass/fail result.

Direct relationships are the asset

The most valuable thing Craftly gives you isn't traffic — it's the right to keep the client.

Once a connection is accepted, the messaging thread is yours. You can share your real phone number, your direct email, your booking link. There's no platform inserting itself between you and a repeat booking. There's no "communicate only through us" rule.

What this means in practice:

  • Convert booked clients into repeat clients. A simple "I'd love to work with you again — feel free to text me directly next time" at the end of a booked engagement is the difference between one job and a recurring relationship.
  • Build a list off the platform. Your client relationships belong to you. Add booked clients to your own newsletter or contact list (with their permission) so you're not dependent on Craftly visibility forever.
  • Refer when you're booked. Refer a fellow Craftly provider when you can't take a job. The referral credit you earn is real, and the goodwill is bigger.

A 30-day starter checklist

If you do nothing else, do these in order during your first month:

  1. Day 1. Publish a profile with: real photo, bio (150+ words), starting price, service area, three portfolio items.
  2. Day 2. Set your delivery preference (SMS recommended for fastest response).
  3. Week 1. Add three more portfolio items with captions. Start the Verified Badge flow.
  4. Week 2. Reply to every connection request within 4 hours during business hours.
  5. Week 3. Ask your first booked Craftly client for a review within 24 hours of completion.
  6. Week 4. Refresh your portfolio order. Add one credential or testimonial. Refer a fellow provider.

That's the whole guide. The rest is reps.

Ready to put this into practice?

Create your free Craftly profile in five minutes and use this handbook as your day-one playbook.